Herpes Treatment Cost & Convenience Calculator
This tool helps you compare the costs, convenience, and effectiveness of antiviral medications for cold sores and herpes outbreaks based on your individual situation.
Your Results
Based on your selections, here's how each medication compares for you.
Zovirax has been the go-to name for cold sores and herpes outbreaks for decades. But with newer options on the shelf and generic versions available, many people wonder: is Zovirax still the best choice? Or are there better, cheaper, or faster alternatives? The answer isn’t simple-it depends on your symptoms, budget, and how often outbreaks happen.
What Zovirax (Acyclovir) Actually Does
Zovirax is the brand name for acyclovir, an antiviral drug that targets the herpes simplex virus (HSV-1 and HSV-2). It doesn’t cure herpes. Instead, it slows down how fast the virus replicates. That means outbreaks heal faster, pain decreases sooner, and you’re contagious for a shorter time.
Acyclovir works best when taken within 24-48 hours of the first tingling or itching sensation-the early warning signs of a cold sore. If you wait until the blister is fully formed, the benefit drops significantly.
It comes in several forms: oral tablets (200mg, 400mg, 800mg), topical cream (5%), and intravenous solution (for severe cases). Most people use the oral version for recurrent outbreaks. The cream helps with surface sores but doesn’t reach deeper layers of skin where the virus hides.
Top Alternatives to Zovirax
Three main antivirals are used for herpes today: acyclovir (Zovirax), valacyclovir (Valtrex), and famciclovir (Famvir). All three work the same way-they block viral DNA replication. But their differences matter in real life.
Valacyclovir (Valtrex)
Valacyclovir is a prodrug of acyclovir. That means your body converts it into acyclovir after you swallow it. The big advantage? Better absorption. You need fewer pills per day.
For cold sores: Take 2,000 mg twice a day for one day. That’s it. No five-day course. Many people find this easier to stick with.
For genital herpes: Once-daily suppression (500 mg) is common. Zovirax would require three to five doses daily for the same effect.
Studies show valacyclovir clears cold sores about half a day faster than acyclovir. It also reduces the chance of transmission to partners by up to 50% when taken daily.
Famciclovir (Famvir)
Famciclovir is another prodrug, converted to penciclovir in the body. It has a longer half-life than acyclovir, meaning it stays active longer.
For cold sores: Take 1,500 mg as a single dose. That’s even simpler than Valtrex.
For genital herpes outbreaks: 1,000 mg twice daily for one day. For suppression: 250 mg twice daily.
One study in the Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology found famciclovir reduced healing time by 1.5 days compared to placebo. It’s slightly more effective than acyclovir but not dramatically so.
Comparing Zovirax, Valtrex, and Famvir
| Feature | Zovirax (Acyclovir) | Valtrex (Valacyclovir) | Famvir (Famciclovir) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dosing for cold sores | 200 mg five times daily for 5 days | 2,000 mg twice daily for 1 day | 1,500 mg once |
| Dosing for genital herpes (outbreak) | 200 mg five times daily for 5-10 days | 1,000 mg twice daily for 1 day | 1,000 mg twice daily for 1 day |
| Dosing for suppression (daily) | 200-400 mg two to five times daily | 500 mg once daily | 250 mg twice daily |
| Average healing time reduction | 1-2 days | 1.5-2.5 days | 1.5-2 days |
| Cost (30-day supply, generic) | $15-$30 | $40-$70 | $50-$80 |
| Best for first-time users | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Best for convenience | No | Yes | Yes |
Here’s the bottom line: Zovirax is the cheapest and has the longest safety record. But Valtrex and Famvir require fewer pills, which improves adherence. If you forget to take your medicine, it won’t work as well.
When to Choose Generic Acyclovir
Generic acyclovir is available in almost every pharmacy for under $10 for a 30-day supply. It’s identical to Zovirax in active ingredient, dosage, and effectiveness. The only difference? The brand name and packaging.
If you’re on a tight budget, or only get outbreaks a few times a year, generic acyclovir is the smart pick. Many people don’t realize they’re paying 10x more for the same drug.
One patient I spoke with, a college student with recurrent cold sores, switched from Zovirax to generic acyclovir and saved $400 a year. Her outbreaks didn’t change in severity or duration.
When to Choose Valtrex or Famvir
Choose Valtrex or Famvir if:
- You struggle to remember to take pills multiple times a day
- You have frequent outbreaks (six or more per year)
- You’re trying to reduce transmission to a partner
- You want the simplest dosing-single-dose treatment for cold sores
Valtrex is the most popular choice for suppression therapy. It’s approved for daily use in people with 6+ outbreaks per year. Famvir is less commonly prescribed for suppression but works just as well.
What About Over-the-Counter Options?
There are OTC creams like Abreva (docosanol) and lysine supplements. They’re marketed as alternatives, but they’re not the same as antiviral pills.
Abreva reduces healing time by about half a day-less than half the effect of acyclovir. It only works on the surface. It doesn’t touch the virus hiding in nerve cells.
Lysine supplements? No high-quality study has proven they prevent or treat outbreaks. The American Academy of Dermatology doesn’t recommend them.
Don’t waste money on these if you’re serious about controlling herpes. They’re not replacements for antivirals.
Side Effects and Safety
All three drugs are very safe. Common side effects include:
- Headache
- Nausea
- Dizziness
- Mild stomach upset
Severe side effects-like kidney problems or confusion-are extremely rare and mostly happen in older adults or people with existing kidney disease.
If you have kidney issues, your doctor may lower your dose. That’s true for all three drugs. No one drug is safer than the others in this group.
Insurance and Cost Realities
Insurance often covers Valtrex and Famvir, but you might pay more out-of-pocket than for generic acyclovir.
At CVS, a 30-day supply of generic acyclovir 400mg costs $18 with a GoodRx coupon. Valtrex 1,000mg? $120 without insurance. Famvir? $135.
But here’s the trick: if you take Valtrex once daily for suppression, you only need 30 pills a month. If you take acyclovir five times daily, you need 150 pills. So the monthly cost of acyclovir for suppression can be $90 or more.
Always check your pharmacy’s discount program. Many offer $10 or $15 generic acyclovir. That’s cheaper than most insurance copays.
Which One Should You Pick?
Here’s a simple decision guide:
- First outbreak? Try generic acyclovir. It works. It’s cheap. You can always switch later.
- Outbreaks every few months? Go with Valtrex. The once- or twice-daily dosing is easier to stick with.
- Want the simplest treatment for cold sores? Try Famvir’s single-dose option. Take it at the first sign and forget it.
- On a strict budget? Stick with generic acyclovir. No need to overpay for the same effect.
- Have kidney problems? Talk to your doctor. All three need dose adjustments.
There’s no "best" drug. There’s only the best drug for you.
What About Newer Drugs?
There are no new antivirals approved for herpes since famciclovir in the late 1990s. Research is focused on vaccines and topical treatments, but nothing has reached market yet.
Don’t fall for "miracle cures" online. No cream, supplement, or laser device can eliminate herpes from your nerves. Only antivirals suppress the virus.
Stick with the proven trio: acyclovir, valacyclovir, famciclovir. They’ve been used safely by millions for over 40 years.
Final Thoughts
Zovirax started the revolution in herpes treatment. But today, you have better options. The key isn’t brand loyalty-it’s matching the drug to your life.
If you take pills easily and want the lowest cost, go with generic acyclovir.
If convenience matters more, Valtrex or Famvir are worth the extra cost.
Either way, start treatment at the first sign of tingling. That’s when it works best.
And remember: herpes doesn’t define you. It’s a common virus. Millions live full, healthy lives with it. The right treatment just makes it easier to manage.
Is Zovirax better than generic acyclovir?
No. Zovirax and generic acyclovir contain the exact same active ingredient, dosage, and strength. The only difference is the brand name and price. Generic acyclovir works just as well and costs up to 90% less.
Can I use Valtrex for cold sores instead of Zovirax?
Yes. Valtrex (valacyclovir) is actually preferred for cold sores because you only need to take two pills 12 hours apart-sometimes just one dose. It works faster and is easier to remember than Zovirax’s five-times-daily regimen.
Is famciclovir better than acyclovir?
Famciclovir (Famvir) is slightly more convenient because it requires fewer doses per day and can be taken as a single dose for cold sores. But its effectiveness is very similar to acyclovir. The choice often comes down to cost and personal preference.
Do I need a prescription for acyclovir or its alternatives?
Yes. All three-acyclovir, valacyclovir, and famciclovir-are prescription-only in the U.S. You can get them from your doctor, a telehealth service, or a clinic. Over-the-counter creams like Abreva are not equivalent.
Can I take these drugs every day to prevent outbreaks?
Yes. Daily suppression therapy with valacyclovir (500 mg once daily) or acyclovir (400 mg twice daily) can reduce outbreaks by 70-80%. It’s safe for long-term use and lowers the risk of spreading herpes to partners.
Are there natural alternatives to Zovirax?
No reliable natural alternatives exist. Lysine supplements, tea tree oil, and zinc creams have no strong scientific proof of effectiveness. Only antiviral medications like acyclovir, valacyclovir, and famciclovir have been proven to shorten outbreaks and reduce transmission.
How soon should I start treatment after I feel a cold sore coming on?
Start treatment within 24 hours of the first tingling, itching, or burning sensation. Waiting until the blister forms reduces the drug’s effectiveness by up to 50%. Act fast-it’s the most important step.
